Time Banking - Economic Science Of Sharing Economic Scheme - Pondering Fourth Dimension Republik
Recently at LETS, a similar project, appear to autumn apart nether to a greater extent than scrutiny. I would similar to verbalize over roughly of the points mentioned amongst you. But first...
Time Republik is a LETS, except using a different unit of measurement of account.
With that information, lets jump into roughly interesting discussion.
It appears that Time Republik was designed to survive mainly used for services, rather than goods. I powerfulness mow your lawn for an hour, too inwards commutation I could receive got someone aid me practise my taxes for an hour. While this is all good too skillful to start, if the fourth dimension units are going to larn a currency, people volition desire to pay amongst them for goods equally well.
Just similar Charlie Shrem illustrated has the properties of money (fungibility, durability, etc.) into money if the demand arises. The same regulation volition apply to the fourth dimension units. Influenza A virus subtype H5N1 soft gulp powerfulness toll a minute, piece a machine powerfulness survive worth a few years. I suppose if a scheme similar this would receive got off, nosotros powerfulness encounter an economic scheme similar to the 1 establish inwards In Time (perhaps shy of people dying because they ran out of time).
Another center regulation of the Time Republik strongly held yesteryear its developers is that 1 hr of anyone's fourth dimension is equal to 1 hr of anyone else's time. In other words, 1 hr of raking the leaves is equal to 1 hr of a medico diagnosis, or an hr of consulting amongst a lawyer.
In general, this scheme is equally good idealistic if people receive got whatsoever gratis choice.
First of all, whatsoever economical scheme wants to eliminate or at to the lowest degree restrict the gratis passenger problem - you lot desire to punish people that slack off too don't practise their jobs equally good well. If I was to pay for an hr of mowing my lawn too someone did it too so carelessly equally to exit patches of tall grass everywhere, I would desire to receive got roughly assort of recourse against them. This is easily done amongst roughly basic reputation system, similar to eBay or Amazon.
However, if nosotros innovate reputation into the system, it volition Pb to roughly other work - operate is no longer fungible. If I receive got the selection betwixt a few people to practise the same job, I would naturally pick the 1 that is best rated, all other things beingness equal. Because everyone thinks the same, the demand for highly rated people goes up, too presently in that location is to a greater extent than demand for them than they tin supply. At that moment, they tin start charging a flake to a greater extent than for their services, so lowering the demand downward to the indicate where the furnish too demand are equal again. It powerfulness survive 1.1 hr units per hr of work, perchance 1.5, 2 or more.
The alone means to address this effect would survive to forcefulness the labourers to survive fungible. It could survive achieved yesteryear a chat-roulette-style scheme - you lot conduct what chore you lot demand done, piece the scheme assigns you lot a labourer that tin practise that task at random. However, this brings us dorsum to our gratis passenger work silent again...
This concept was strongly expressed inwards our Decentral chat amongst the folks from LETS, merely was also introduce inwards the give-and-take amongst Time Republik. The sentiment is that both of the systems desire to practise a local economic scheme yesteryear creating a currency that should non survive traded for other currencies, because that would defeat the indicate of the system. If a local currency is tradeable on a global marketplace, it stops becoming a local currency too the money leaves the community.
This concept isn't novel - pretty much every companionship hosting MMO games has to address this issue. This is truthful for CCP too EVE Online, equally good equally Blizzard too World of Warcraft. If in that location is no white marketplace for your currency, in that location volition survive a grayness or dark marketplace to fill upwards that void.
While inwards the quondam days it might've been plenty to impress roughly local newspaper money that nobody exterior of a given surface area would survive interested inwards to reign inwards how far the money travels, amongst today's seamless global Crypto 2.0 systems similar Ripple, whatsoever currency deployed on that scheme gets turned into a global currency equally presently equally someone puts upwards a merchandise for it. Money knows no boundaries, too it volition notice its value.
Another work of bootstrapping an economic scheme is how you lot distribute the currency units. At the moment, Time Republik gives anyone that signs upwards for their scheme a few gratis hours they tin pass on the system. While it's a skillful start, the scheme powerfulness speedily survive exploited yesteryear mechanical turk-like networks. In the long run, roughly different token distribution method would demand to survive devised.
Influenza A virus subtype H5N1 possible solution to the work powerfulness survive to start everyone amongst zip hours too allow them earn the tokens from other people inwards the network. To add together to a greater extent than tokens to the network, Time Republik could organize roughly projects to practise goodness the community that anyone could participate inwards - social media campaigns, cleaning the parks, charity work, etc. This would hateful that every hr inwards the scheme came from an hr of operate too laissez passer on it roughly underlying value.
That beingness said, it is understandable from user sense perspective that a scheme allowing you lot to directly dip your toes inwards too start spending inwards the novel economic scheme is much to a greater extent than welcoming than the 1 that requires you lot to earn your money first.
Another indicate inwards our give-and-take was the sentiment that money can't purchase trust. Thinking nearly it initially, it seems obvious - giving someone money doesn't brand them larn your friends too all that. However, if you lot interruption too intend nearly it, maybe in that location is roughly means money tin purchase you lot trust?
Say I desire to borrow your wheel for a few hours. If I'm your friend, that's non an effect - you lot volition gladly borrow me the bike, since you lot know that inwards the yesteryear I could survive relied to receive got skillful attention of borrowed items too render similar favours. If I'm a stranger, you lot can't actually nation if I'm an honest or dishonest person, too so you lot would survive understandably unlikely to allow me borrow your bike.
However, what if I offered you lot a safety deposit for that bike? If I deposited amongst you lot to a greater extent than than it would toll you lot to supplant that wheel too you lot were gratis to purpose that money for whatsoever repairs to the impairment I might've caused, you lot would survive to a greater extent than probable to lend me the bike. Influenza A virus subtype H5N1 similar province of affairs could arise if I had roughly money reserve at a 3rd political party too would concord to pose it inwards escrow amongst a trusted 3rd party.
While this powerfulness non actually survive a means to purchase or earn trust, it tin survive a useful plenty proxy when we're talking nearly work organisation arrangements.
While Time Republik looks similar a actually interesting projection needed for social change, creating a novel economic scheme without agreement how the electrical flow model industrial plant or without thinking similar a malicious soul bent on abusing the scheme tin exit a lot of gaps that would demand to survive filled at roughly point.
Sumber http://tpbit.blogspot.com/
What is Time Republik?
Time Republik is a LETS, except using a different unit of measurement of account.
With that information, lets jump into roughly interesting discussion.
Time is for services
It appears that Time Republik was designed to survive mainly used for services, rather than goods. I powerfulness mow your lawn for an hour, too inwards commutation I could receive got someone aid me practise my taxes for an hour. While this is all good too skillful to start, if the fourth dimension units are going to larn a currency, people volition desire to pay amongst them for goods equally well.
Just similar Charlie Shrem illustrated has the properties of money (fungibility, durability, etc.) into money if the demand arises. The same regulation volition apply to the fourth dimension units. Influenza A virus subtype H5N1 soft gulp powerfulness toll a minute, piece a machine powerfulness survive worth a few years. I suppose if a scheme similar this would receive got off, nosotros powerfulness encounter an economic scheme similar to the 1 establish inwards In Time (perhaps shy of people dying because they ran out of time).
1 hr = 1 hour
Another center regulation of the Time Republik strongly held yesteryear its developers is that 1 hr of anyone's fourth dimension is equal to 1 hr of anyone else's time. In other words, 1 hr of raking the leaves is equal to 1 hr of a medico diagnosis, or an hr of consulting amongst a lawyer.
In general, this scheme is equally good idealistic if people receive got whatsoever gratis choice.
First of all, whatsoever economical scheme wants to eliminate or at to the lowest degree restrict the gratis passenger problem - you lot desire to punish people that slack off too don't practise their jobs equally good well. If I was to pay for an hr of mowing my lawn too someone did it too so carelessly equally to exit patches of tall grass everywhere, I would desire to receive got roughly assort of recourse against them. This is easily done amongst roughly basic reputation system, similar to eBay or Amazon.
However, if nosotros innovate reputation into the system, it volition Pb to roughly other work - operate is no longer fungible. If I receive got the selection betwixt a few people to practise the same job, I would naturally pick the 1 that is best rated, all other things beingness equal. Because everyone thinks the same, the demand for highly rated people goes up, too presently in that location is to a greater extent than demand for them than they tin supply. At that moment, they tin start charging a flake to a greater extent than for their services, so lowering the demand downward to the indicate where the furnish too demand are equal again. It powerfulness survive 1.1 hr units per hr of work, perchance 1.5, 2 or more.
The alone means to address this effect would survive to forcefulness the labourers to survive fungible. It could survive achieved yesteryear a chat-roulette-style scheme - you lot conduct what chore you lot demand done, piece the scheme assigns you lot a labourer that tin practise that task at random. However, this brings us dorsum to our gratis passenger work silent again...
Currency should survive local
This concept was strongly expressed inwards our Decentral chat amongst the folks from LETS, merely was also introduce inwards the give-and-take amongst Time Republik. The sentiment is that both of the systems desire to practise a local economic scheme yesteryear creating a currency that should non survive traded for other currencies, because that would defeat the indicate of the system. If a local currency is tradeable on a global marketplace, it stops becoming a local currency too the money leaves the community.
This concept isn't novel - pretty much every companionship hosting MMO games has to address this issue. This is truthful for CCP too EVE Online, equally good equally Blizzard too World of Warcraft. If in that location is no white marketplace for your currency, in that location volition survive a grayness or dark marketplace to fill upwards that void.
While inwards the quondam days it might've been plenty to impress roughly local newspaper money that nobody exterior of a given surface area would survive interested inwards to reign inwards how far the money travels, amongst today's seamless global Crypto 2.0 systems similar Ripple, whatsoever currency deployed on that scheme gets turned into a global currency equally presently equally someone puts upwards a merchandise for it. Money knows no boundaries, too it volition notice its value.
Distribution problem
Another work of bootstrapping an economic scheme is how you lot distribute the currency units. At the moment, Time Republik gives anyone that signs upwards for their scheme a few gratis hours they tin pass on the system. While it's a skillful start, the scheme powerfulness speedily survive exploited yesteryear mechanical turk-like networks. In the long run, roughly different token distribution method would demand to survive devised.
Influenza A virus subtype H5N1 possible solution to the work powerfulness survive to start everyone amongst zip hours too allow them earn the tokens from other people inwards the network. To add together to a greater extent than tokens to the network, Time Republik could organize roughly projects to practise goodness the community that anyone could participate inwards - social media campaigns, cleaning the parks, charity work, etc. This would hateful that every hr inwards the scheme came from an hr of operate too laissez passer on it roughly underlying value.
That beingness said, it is understandable from user sense perspective that a scheme allowing you lot to directly dip your toes inwards too start spending inwards the novel economic scheme is much to a greater extent than welcoming than the 1 that requires you lot to earn your money first.
Money can't purchase trust
Another indicate inwards our give-and-take was the sentiment that money can't purchase trust. Thinking nearly it initially, it seems obvious - giving someone money doesn't brand them larn your friends too all that. However, if you lot interruption too intend nearly it, maybe in that location is roughly means money tin purchase you lot trust?
Say I desire to borrow your wheel for a few hours. If I'm your friend, that's non an effect - you lot volition gladly borrow me the bike, since you lot know that inwards the yesteryear I could survive relied to receive got skillful attention of borrowed items too render similar favours. If I'm a stranger, you lot can't actually nation if I'm an honest or dishonest person, too so you lot would survive understandably unlikely to allow me borrow your bike.
However, what if I offered you lot a safety deposit for that bike? If I deposited amongst you lot to a greater extent than than it would toll you lot to supplant that wheel too you lot were gratis to purpose that money for whatsoever repairs to the impairment I might've caused, you lot would survive to a greater extent than probable to lend me the bike. Influenza A virus subtype H5N1 similar province of affairs could arise if I had roughly money reserve at a 3rd political party too would concord to pose it inwards escrow amongst a trusted 3rd party.
While this powerfulness non actually survive a means to purchase or earn trust, it tin survive a useful plenty proxy when we're talking nearly work organisation arrangements.
Conclusions
While Time Republik looks similar a actually interesting projection needed for social change, creating a novel economic scheme without agreement how the electrical flow model industrial plant or without thinking similar a malicious soul bent on abusing the scheme tin exit a lot of gaps that would demand to survive filled at roughly point.
Sumber http://tpbit.blogspot.com/
Post a Comment for "Time Banking - Economic Science Of Sharing Economic Scheme - Pondering Fourth Dimension Republik"